Unjournal team members: internal notes on these papers (possible conflicts, team discussion, outreach) are on a Notion page. Open it if you have access, or ask contact@unjournal.org.
How to use this page
Each row is one paper. Click a title to open its brief: what it says, why it matters, how well it fits an Unjournal evaluation, and how much attention it is getting now.
- One rating scale. Every row has the quick scale
---~+++, so you can work straight down the list. Each step stands for a priority percentile (10, 30, 50, 70, 90). Clicking one opens the rating panel with that value chosen; add a percentile or a comment if you like, then save. - The panel keeps the brief visible, and Next steps through the list. Use Close or Escape to return to the list. Unsubmitted edits stay in the panel during this visit; use Save rating to submit. Ratings count on the dashboard too.
- For private remarks (possible evaluators, conflicts, concerns), use the panel's discussion box and set it to Unjournal team only.
- Filter with the bar above the list; click a column heading to sort by it. The list starts sorted by attention.
Hover or tab to any dotted label for an explanation.
Where your ratings go
- Ratings use the dashboard's own rating form, so they appear in the same aggregates and follow the same privacy rules. You choose who can see any discussion you add.
- Everyone can see the tally. The Ratings so far column shows all current ratings of each paper, without names. Try to form your own view first; this is a rough exercise, not a precise one.
- Earlier Keep/Maybe/Drop picks. Until 6 Oct 2026 this page had a separate Keep/Maybe/Drop pick. Those picks now count as ratings: Keep =
+, Maybe =~, Drop =-. If the same person also rated the paper, their rating counts instead, and rating a paper now replaces your converted pick. The original pick counts are still available: tick Show original Keep/Maybe/Drop picks above the list. Notes sent with picks stay private. - No double counting. This page and the dashboard share one rater key per browser. Rating a paper here and then on the dashboard (or the reverse) updates one rating; it does not add a second.
- Your name and email are saved in this browser and reused by the dashboard's forms. They are never published.
Annotate with Hypothes.is
Select any text on this page and choose Annotate, or open the sidebar from the tab on the right edge of the window. You need a free Hypothes.is account.
Annotations on the public layer are visible to everyone. Public Hypothes.is comments may be incorporated into The Unjournal's knowledge base and quoted, summarized or reposted on other public Unjournal channels. For private remarks, use the note box in a brief instead.
| ?Where the paper sits in the working list: shortlist, getting attention now, alternates, found on the dashboard, or older papers kept because they are still in use. | ? | ?In window: released or substantially revised since April 2026. Theory: older, but exempt because the contribution is theoretical. Borderline: just outside. Older: fails the recency rule but is still in use. | Links | ?Everyone’s published ratings, including yours if it has reached the latest refresh. Human judgments only; AI scores are separate on the dashboard. Quick ratings use -- 10 · - 30 · ~ 50 · + 70 · ++ 90; exact percentiles are shown at the nearest step, with the plain average. Earlier Keep/Maybe/Drop picks count as + / ~ / -. Try to form your own view before looking. | ? |
|---|