Overview, audio, and help
Unjournal team members: internal notes on these papers (possible conflicts, team discussion, outreach) are on a Notion page. Open it if you have access, or ask contact@unjournal.org.
How to use this page
Each row is one paper. Click a title to open its brief: what it says, why it matters, how well it fits an Unjournal evaluation, and how much attention it is getting now.
- One rating scale. Choose Compare & rate to see the quick scale in every row:
---~+++, so you can make a quick first pass and return to your leading candidates. Each step stands for a priority percentile (10, 30, 50, 70, 90). Clicking one opens the rating panel with that value chosen; add a percentile or a comment if you like, then save. - The panel keeps the brief visible, and Next steps through the list. Use Close or Escape to return to the list. Unsubmitted edits stay in the panel during this visit; use Save rating to submit. Ratings count on the dashboard too.
- For private remarks (possible evaluators, conflicts, concerns), use the panel's discussion box and set it to Unjournal team only.
- Filter with the bar above the list; click a column heading to sort by it. The list starts sorted by attention.
Hover or tab to any dotted label for an explanation.
Where your ratings go
- Ratings use the dashboard's own rating form, so they appear in the same aggregates and follow the same privacy rules. You choose who can see any discussion you add.
- Everyone can see the tally. In Compare & rate, the All human ratings column shows all current ratings of each paper, without names. Try to form your own view first; this is a rough exercise, not a precise one.
- Earlier Keep/Maybe/Drop picks. Until 6 Oct 2026 this page had a separate Keep/Maybe/Drop pick. Those picks now count as ratings: Keep =
+, Maybe =~, Drop =-. If the same person also rated the paper, their rating counts instead, and rating a paper now replaces your converted pick. The original pick counts are still available: tick Show original Keep/Maybe/Drop picks above the list. Notes sent with picks stay private. - No double counting. This page and the dashboard share one rater key per browser. Rating a paper here and then on the dashboard (or the reverse) updates one rating; it does not add a second.
- Your name and email are saved in this browser and reused by the dashboard's forms. They are never published.
Your rater profile and saved ratings
| ?Sort order: selected for evaluation, working shortlist, getting attention now, alternates, other candidates, then older papers. Topic and source groups share the other-candidate level; their labels alone do not establish proximity to evaluation. Selected papers retain any outstanding objection condition. Click the heading again to reverse. | ? | ?Paper dates use the latest release or revision recorded in each brief, not when we added it. Month-only dates are approximate; the three-month filter includes months that overlap its window. In window: released or substantially revised since April 2026. Theory: older, but exempt because the contribution is theoretical. Borderline: just outside. Older: fails the recency rule but is still in use. | Read | ?Everyone’s published ratings, including yours if it has reached the latest refresh. AI ratings are available through the Ratings shown control. Quick ratings use -- 10 · - 30 · ~ 50 · + 70 · ++ 90; exact percentiles are shown at the nearest step, with the plain average. Earlier Keep/Maybe/Drop picks count as + / ~ / -. Try to form your own view before looking. | ? |
|---|